The Worst of Bowie? A Bottom-10 list (that includes some songs I personally like)
I write about Bowie daily and find something to like in almost everything he released. Almost. But even if you are of the opinion that Bowie was incapable of recording a truly terrible song, few would argue that everything he did was of equal value. The following is my latest attempt at a list of ten candidates for the distinction of Bowie’s “worst” song– this is not a rank-ordered list (it’s in chronological order), and in some cases I like some of these songs, but I’ll try to explain the case for why each might occupy the very bottom of the Bowie barrel:
1. “Do Anything You Say,” 1966. It’s tough to ascertain which of Bowie’s singles was the least commercially successful, but a case can be made that the distinction falls to this, the very first single simply attributed to “David Bowie” (not counting earlier singles attributed to David Bowie and the Lower Third, Davy or Davie Jones or the Mannish Boys). I have seen speculation that a slightly later single, “Rubber Band” was his least successful. Personally, I think “Rubber Band” is a worse song, but since it was included in the Love You ‘Til Tuesday project, regardless of its sales it received more attention than this all-but-forgotten early effort. Bowie might have been willing to “do anything” for a hit in the mid-60s, but if “worst” is measured by sales alone, then this one might take the prize.
2. “Uncle Arthur,” 1967. This is my nominee for Bowie’s absolute worst. I admit it, I do not like Bowie’s self-titled debut album and there are several songs I especially don’t like. What stands out about this one is it is the very first song on the very first Bowie album. When Rykodisc began releasing Bowie’s back catalogue on CD starting in 1990, they skipped over his first, so a generation of us can be forgiven for thinking the album now known as Space Oddity (1969) was Bowie’s debut. I mention this because — think about it– which song would you rather have had your album catalogue begin with– “Space Oddity”… or “Uncle Arthur”? I rest my case unless, that is, you don’t know “Uncle Arthur.” If so, do yourself a favor, think like Rykodisc and just skip it.
3. “The Laughing Gnome,” 1967. I once wrote something along the lines of this being inarguably Bowie’s worst song. It remains a kind of go-to for fans pressed to name a Bowie misfire. Meant to be comedic, this pun-heavy novelty number features a sped-up voice gnome telling gnome jokes. Bowie himself would joke about it later, and today some fans have expressed affection for the song. In my current opinion, an even worse attempt at a funny song that Bowie wrote was the far more obscure “Over the Wall We Go” about a prison break. That song, was recorded and released by “Oscar” (actually Paul Nicholas) in 1967 and was a flop. A demo performed by Bowie exists out there, and if you ever come across it, do yourself a favor and listen to something funnier, like “The Laughing Gnome.”
4. “Revolutionary Song,” 1979. I get the sense that the folks who made Just A Gigolo, a film Bowie basically disowned, desperately wanted to be able to say that he contributed to the soundtrack. So, Bowie slapped something together that includes him singing “la-la-la.” The result sounds fragmentary and in the days before YouTube was somewhat hard to find. It should have stayed that way.
5. “God Only Knows,” 1984. OK, here I have to admit that I actually like Bowie’s cover of this Beach Boys song. But it evokes anger and even hatred in others. Bowie chronicler Nicholas Pegg wrote that it is “perhaps the worst track he ever recorded.” I have an unproven theory that if you like this song, you like the album Tonight, and if you don’t, you don’t. (I like Tonight).
6. Pepsi Commercial, 1985 (AKA “Creation”). Bowie and Tina Turner teamed up to do a Pepsi commercial loosely based on the movie Weird Science, for which Bowie changed the lyrics of “Modern Love” to help sell cola. Sounds like a good idea, right? The actual music is pretty much “Modern Love,” so the problem with this is more conceptual. If “selling out” means anything, it means this. This is not the only commercial Bowie ever made, and it isn’t even the only music he ever adapted for a commercial, but somehow, “Crystal Japan” seems to carry more artistic integrity (maybe because outside of Japan, where it was used to sell a beverage, it is regarded as a rarity).
7. “Dancing in the Street,” 1985. Here’s another one that I actually like, but it tops some “worst” lists, including a 2023 list posted by Far Out Magazine (linked HERE). My read on the heat this song gets is that some fans were expecting something different, more serious and more innovative. Instead, Bowie and Mick Jagger sound like they were just having fun. That’s good enough for many of us— this was a #1 hit for a reason. But it clearly makes others want to take to the street — in protest.
8. “Chilly Down,” 1986. If you like Labyrinth, one of the things you probably like about it is that Bowie doesn’t just act, but he sings original songs. Accepting that his target audience in this case was children, Bowie’s success in that regard is a testament to his range and adaptability. That said, he wisely left this stinker to the Muppets. There’s a demo with Bowie singing this out there, but he only gets the writing credit on the soundtrack. This is for the best.
9. “Too Dizzy,” 1987. This one has an especially bad reputation because Bowie disliked it so much that he arranged for it to be removed from reissues of the album it originally appeared on, Never Let Me Down. I find this somewhat odd because the song just doesn’t leave much of a mark on me. Had it not been removed by Bowie, it wouldn’t have occurred to me to add it to this list, and if I was pressed to include something from the album, it probably would be “Shining Star (Makin’ My Love)” with its infamous Mickey Rourke rap. Did that really happen? Yes, it did. And yes, that cassette you bought of Never Let Me Down in the 80s had an extra song on it.
10. “Stateside,” 1991. I more or less agree with Bowie blogger Chris O’Leary, who wrote, “Dreadful as it is, Hunt Sales’ ‘Stateside’ doesn’t quite seem to merit the collective hatred it’s inspired.” But for present purposes the important thing to note here is that the song inspires hatred. It’s one of two Tin Machine songs where Sales takes lead on vocals and Bowie sings backup. I suspect that had this appeared on a Hunt Sales album, with Bowie as a guest musician, it would be thought of like Scarlett Johansson’s ‘Fannin Street’—a song he appeared on but that isn’t really considered a Bowie song. This one, I think, again falls victim to expectations, which were along the lines of Tin Machine being Bowie’s backup band, rather than a “democratic” group. Plus it is long. Which can also be said about this list, so before this qualifies for the “Worst of Worst of Lists” list, I’ll wrap it up.
—
So what do you think? If these are the nominees, which should be the “winner” (which is to say, loser)? What’s not on this list? What’s your least favorite, or are you of the view that everything Bowie did was great? Let me know!