Skip to content

Week 85 | Is It Any Wonder? (2020)

Bowie’s posthumous career continues going strong with this brief but welcomed compilation of material from around the “Earthling” period of 1997. This EP contains six songs, none of which I recall coming across before in the form they appear on this album. I (began) writing this as I am listening to the album for the first time. My initial impression is very positive— it sounds great. Similar to the drum-and-bass style of “Earthling,” but by and large more ambient and not as aggressive.

Two of the songs do not appear on any other studio album— “Nuts” is totally new to me— a near-instrumental piece of club music, and “Fun,” which I think was the B-side to the song, “Little Wonder” (a song which, oddly, does not appear in this collection). Somewhere along the line I have heard some version of “Fun” (this one is called the “Clownboy Mix”) but until now I never owned a copy of it. I like both of these songs, which together are the anchors of the collection.

Starting with, “Low,” Bowie was never afraid of including instrumentals on his albums. In the mid-90s, starting with “Pallas Athena” on Black Tie White Noise (1993), Bowie began churning out danceable songs with few words, often featuring a distorted version of his voice. “Nuts” is another of this type, along with songs like “Sex and the Church” (1993); “Telling Lies” (1997) and the later song, “Queen of All The Tarts” (2003). If anything, it sounds more like an outtake from “1. Outside,” in that Bowie’s voice distortions sound like one of his characters that speak through that album’s various segues. I actually like the instrumental songs from this period better than most of Bowie’s better regarded late 1970’s instrumentals — they are generally more melodic and, while not heavy on words, at least feature Bowie’s voice in some way.

From time to time, especially later in his career, Bowie would come out with a song that seems related to an earlier song but really isn’t. “Hallo Spaceboy” (1995), is probably the best example of this— with its references to “moon dust” and confusion over liking girls or boys. Is it autobiographical? Is it about the return of the pre-1980s Bowie? The song can be heard that way, but who knows? In the same way, it is tough to listen to, “Fun,” without thinking of Iggy Pop’s, “Funhouse.” The most repeated word in both songs is indeed, “funhouse.” The word, “fun” is also repeated in Bowie’s, “Fun,” much as it is in the Iggy-Bowie collaboration, “Funtime.” Is there more of a connection? I don’t see it, but Bowie had to have been aware that he was giving hardcore fans something to think about, even if the thought doesn’t lead anywhere. Beyond that, though, I like the way the song sounds.

The album’s other four songs are “new” versions of old songs, all of which work. “Stay,” is one of my favorite songs, and this version, “Stay ‘97,” sounds different enough from the original but not because it is simply an inferior version of the same arrangement. “The Man Who Sold the World,” had, by the mid-90s, been resurrected by Nirvana. After that, Bowie reintroduced it to his setlist and kept it thereafter. But he sometimes changed how he’d perform the song— I saw him perform a more industrial version in 1995 while he was promoting, “1. Outside,” and this version, which I had never heard before, is more in line with the style of “Earthling.”

The two other songs are of a type I had long wanted him to perform more — Tin Machine songs. When Tin Machine was a around and touring, I was never in the same city and thus never saw the band live. In fact, although I have seen guitarist Reeves Gabrels perform a Tin Machine song live, I have never seen Bowie do so. This album contains newer versions of “Baby Universal” and “I Can’t Read.” I like both of these versions better than the originals. I have long thought of “I Can’t Read” as one of the unnecessarily preachy songs from the first Tin Machine album. Over the years I have come to think that there are subtleties to the song that are not apparent at first— the song is not so much about illiteracy as about some unstated thing that happened. It isn’t just that the narrator cant read, but that he can’t read anymore. Something happened, either to the narrator’s ability to read, or his tolerance for what it is he would be reading. In any case, the original version is loud and clanky, and placed among overt songs about other societal ills. This one is more subdued, which helps bring the subtleties out.

“Baby Universal” is the opening song on the second Tin Machine album. I haven’t quite thought of it as a throwaway song, but it also isn’t a standout. This version just sounds better. It is similar to, “Fun,” in the sense that it is vaguely resonant of something seemingly familiar. In this case, the song might be about a space alien. Bowie had given up on aliens, stars and space for years after the “Ziggy Stardust” album, only overtly returning with his Major Tom character appearing in the 1980 song, “Ashes to Ashes.” Bowie continued to keep the aliens references few and far between through most of the 1980s — even, “Loving the Alien,” turns out not to be about space aliens at all. But the space references picked up again in the 90s, and the original “Baby Universal” (1991) marked the beginning of the resurrection, followed by such songs as the aforementioned “Hallo Spaceboy” (1995), “Looking for Satellites” (1997), “I Took A Trip on A Gemini Spaceship” (2002); “New Killer Star” (2003); several songs from, “The Next Day” (2013) and finally, obliquely, “Blackstar.” If this version of “Baby Universal” was originally intended for the album Bowie ultimately called, “Earthling,” he surely wanted to evoke his own past.

At the risk of getting too sidetracked on this point— I think what Bowie was trying to do by the 90s and for the rest of his career was to remind people that he was David Bowie. For most of the 80s, Bowie was not just changing his persona but distancing himself from his past. The first Tin Machine album was there apex of this strategy. Bowie attempted to make dramatic jump away from being a stadium-packing pop star to a band-member whose name didn’t even appear on the album cover. Many of the songs on that album do not celebrate hedonism, or revel in the breakdown of societal norms, which were recurrent themes of some of Bowie’s earlier work, but instead speak to the horrendous consequences of those same phenomena. If Bowie confused love with the side effects of cocaine in, “Station to Station,” he sang about “Crack City” on “Tin Machine.” Instead of celebrating the pretty things, who were driving their mammas and papas insane, he resurrected the line, “oh, you pretty thing,” for the menacing Tin Machine song, “Pretty Thing”. Moreover, where Bowie songs up through the 1980s were characterized by obscure, indecipherable lyrics, most of the songs from “Tin Machine” left little up to interpretation.

But by that point, Bowie’s reputation had been collapsing on itself. His late 80’s material sold well but was not well received by many critics and long-time fans. I liked and still like the album, “Tin Machine,” and I remember it being relatively well received at the time. But it was kind of a retreat. Bowie was thumbing his nose at the the generation of fans that first encountered him as Jareth the Goblin King. He shrunk his own stage and his own profile. And then he couldn’t stick with it. While Bowie would regularly change motifs, 1990 and 1991 was the only time that he would flip back and forth. Around that time he was both the frontman for Tin Machine, playing clubs and small venues, he was alternately re-releasing his back catalogue, releasing an innovative archival box set (“Sound and Vision”), and playing arenas on a greatest hits tour.

Which brings us back to, “Baby Universal.” The original version of that song was relatively undistinguished on, “Tin Machine 2,” and the album itself ranks as one of Bowie’s more obscure. Like its predecessor, Bowie’s name doesn’t appear on the album’s front cover— but this time neither did his face. And as I’ve written before, maybe Led Zeppelin and Van Hallen could get away with giving different albums the same name (which was also the name of the band), but that strategy did not help with the promotion of the “Tin Machine 2.” Add to that, two of the album’s songs don’t even feature Bowie singing lead vocals. That doesn’t mean that the (other) songs on that album are bad. Admittedly I don’t listen to it through all too often, but the “new” version of “Baby Universal” reminds us that there’s value in what’s there.

A challenge with posthumous releases is that it cannot truly contain anything that did not exist, even if unreleased, for some time. Any “new” Bowie album necessarily is resonant of past Bowie, because Bowie’s contribution to the works happened years ago. So, “Is it Any Wonder?” seems like a good companion piece to, “Earthing,” because of the way it sounds and the period its contents were originally recorded. But four of the songs harken back further, and oddly, the title is a line from, “Fame,” which was from an even earlier phase in Bowie’s career.

I imagine that there’s much more material out in the world that Bowie recorded but never released. He performed live for decades, and I assume that far more of his concerts were recorded than have been released as live albums (though there a lot of live albums now). There are loads of B-sides and guest appearances on other peoples’ albums that as far as I know have yet to be pulled together into a single collection. But the prospect of songs like what appear on, “Is It Any Wonder?” is most promising to me— music that not only is unfamiliar and sounds good, but is also stylistically coherent. These songs sound like they are supposed to be together. So I’m pretty satisfied and look forward to more collections like this.

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top