Thoughts on Jaws
This post is not about David Bowie. Come back tomorrow for more Bowie, or check out some of my past posts. Otherwise, please enjoy this post about Jaws.
—-
There are two movies we make a point of watching every year— around Christmas we watch Elf, and in the summer we watch Jaws. While Jaws is not my all-time favorite movie, it is nearly perfect and never seems to get old. I can probably watch it a few times a year. But before this year, I never read the book. I do read The Atlantic magazine, and this past June I read an article in it by Tyler Austin Harper about Jaws. Specifically, it was about how the book was different than the movie, and more specifically than that, the main difference revolved around class:
“In the novel, [author Peter] Benchley portrays Amity as a community trying to maintain its dignity in the face of shark-induced uncertainty and the people who live there as mostly noble, if unpolished. But the film, directed by Steven Spielberg, shows little patience for Amity’s fishermen and small-business owners, a perspective that at points seems to devolve into contempt.”
So, this summer, in addition to watching the movie, I decided to read the book. Also, in a state akin to a shark’s blood frenzy, I watched Jaws 2. I enjoyed all of this, but came away with a very different conclusion than Harper’s.
First— as with all great fantasy movies and monster movies (Jaws is both), there’s at least one analogy going on, and in Jaws there’s maybe more than one. Though I kind of see what Harper was saying, the movies — and here I’m including Jaws 2) were really not about class warfare. They are about work avoidance. Work avoidance is a term I got from a class to describe the behavior of groups, and often people, to come up with excuses not to address a real problem in part by putting effort into solving a fake, or at least lesser problem. The town leaders didn’t want to make the tough efforts to solve their shark problem and instead argued with Chief Brody, the main character, about keeping the beaches open to preserve the summer season.
And more than that, especially in Jaws 2, the movies are about the lengths to which people will avoid seeing what they are seeing, and how the group will reinforce this tendency of the individual. In this respect Jaws 2 was Don’t Look Up 45 years before Don’t Look Up.
So, about Jaws 2. Jaws 2 is, in many respects, a typical 1970s sequel that simply tries to capitalize on the success of its predecessor without doing too much new or innovative. It is an entertaining enough, if somewhat absurd movie with two outstanding aspects. The first is that it had one of the most memorable tag lines in movie history— “Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the water…”. Yep, that’s from Jaws 2.
The second outstanding element of this movie is less well recognized, but to me, it does a better job than anything else I can think of in depicting how we will just refuse to see what we don’t want to see. In the original Jaws, the Mayor and others really don’t want to admit that swimming is dangerous. They ignore all the evidence and make decisions based on the explanation for what’s happening that most aligns with the town’s economic goals— the beaches stay open. The shark threat isn’t real. The same dynamic is at play in the second movie, except more is made that the Mayor has allies— businesspeople and other elected officials. Brody is eventually fired for insisting that a new shark has arrived.
OK, nothing new. But there’s this one sequence that borders on the profound. Brody acquires a picture of the shark. It isn’t entirely clear, but we in the audience see what Brody sees— the shark’s unmistakable eye, the texture of its skin, the curve of its mouth. It is a picture of a shark. (How the picture came to be is ridiculous, but I’ll leave it to you to see that sequence in the movie for yourself). Anyway, Brody shows the picture to the Mayor and the Board of Selectmen. None of them could see the shark in the picture. Instead of addressing the problem, they fire Brody — and more people die as a result.
The lessons for the present day are too obvious to enumerate. If you don’t see it without me explicitly explaining, you should run for the Amity Board of Selectmen. You’ll fit in well. But rather than pivoting to how we, as a society in 2025 have become like the selectmen, I want instead to pivot to the book and get back to Harper’s observation about class.
Harper’s point has to do with the differences between the working class characters who live in Amity year-round, and the wealthy outsiders who either come there for the summer or came and never left. In the movie (at this point I’ve finished with Jaws 2, and so by “the movie” from here on out, I mean the original) Harper is able to make this point mostly around the character of Matt Hooper, played by Richard Dreyfuss. Hooper is a rich outsider who understands what’s actually happening and locks horns with the Mayor, who refuses to. Hooper is an entirely sympathetic character, but to Harper, he’s an elite know-it-all up against provincial rubes who don’t know what’s best for them. What’s the matter with Kansas?
Except that Harper’s point falls apart pretty quickly with the movie. Brody, played by Roy Scheider, is also entirely sympathetic, and is also an outsider — but is a working-class policeman. The Mayor, played by Murray Hamilton, may be a local, but he’s not portrayed as working-class. There’s a comic relief scene involving some bumpkins trying to catch the shark with a pot roast, and there’s a scene where a flotilla of amateurs go shark hunting on overcrowded boats, using dynamite and drinking a lot. But even in this scene it is well established that many of the drunk fishermen are outsiders. The main character who is both a local and working-class is Quint, the fisherman who specializes in catching sharks played by Robert Shaw. And once again, in the movie, he’s entirely sympathetic. So, essentially, just looking at the movie side of the equation, Harper’s observation is almost entirely based on Hooper being smart. And that explains why MAGA hates elites. Or something like that.
OK, ok, I’m oversimplifying the point because the other side of the equation— the book— is indeed more overt about class differences. And, importantly, Hooper is a jerk. Not only is he a jerk, but he pretty much contributes nothing to the situation. He’s entirely unsympathetic in the book. But here’s the thing— none of them are. None of the characters are sympathetic. Brody is also a jerk, who, the book establishes early on, is an active contributor to the agreed-upon unwritten ways of the town to cover up unpleasant news, looks the other way when crime — including a serial rapist— could make Amity less attractive a place for outsiders to spend their summer dollars, and bends pretty quickly to the Mayor’s objections to closing the beaches because of the shark. Plus, he’s unpleasant and mean to his wife. His wife, Ellen, who is also entirely sympathetic in the movie, is, in the book, one of those upper-class summer people who “married down,” and ends up cheating on Brody with Hooper. Ellen and Hooper are depicted as using each other to the point that she had to remind him that she was present during sex, and that, once Hooper dies (yeah, he dies in the book— sorry), she doesn’t really care. The Mayor is not simply a practitioner of work avoidance, but he’s under the thumb of the mob because of bad choices he made years before. And Quint likes to torture animals, and has been saving a dolphin fetus he took from a pregnant dolphin he killed. He is working-class, but I don’t think we are supposed to like the Quint of the book. The movie is less guilty of making the elites look good at the expense of the working stiffs as much as it is guilty of making everyone look good, whereas in the book everyone looks bad. Even the Mayor, in the movie, has understandable motives — he’s wrong, but we can see his point of view. In the book, he’s not just wrong— he’s corrupt.
So, there’s one other character in the book who is entirely unsympathetic— the shark. The shark is no King Kong — a beast that is both scary and oddly heroic. We feel bad for Kong when he’s finally killed, after being snatched from his home and put in a situation not of his own making. But the shark is evil.
Evil? Yes. There’s a lot of dialogue in the book between characters who make the point that the shark is not evil, but is just doing what sharks do. But they are saying this while also observing that this particular shark is definitely not doing what sharks do. Why is he stalking Amity? Nobody knows. Sharks don’t do that. Why is he behaving like he’s smart and even strategic? Nobody knows, sharks are supposed to be dumb. Is he grinning when he’s attacking? Uh, no, that’s just what their mouths look like. Supposedly.
Actually, there’s a minor character (the postmistress) in the book who is pretty sure she knows why the shark is doing what it’s doing— it’s sowing retribution on a sinful community. The shark is an instrument of divine justice. Is she another local rube? Putting aside Harper’s thoughts that we shouldn’t think of the locals as rubes, her theory kinda works. The town itself makes money off a lie that all its residents conspire to promulgate. Each of the individual characters is depicted as, well, sinning. In that Quint, Hooper, and the others keep protesting that the shark is just a shark, they too are willfully not seeing what is obvious to us, the reader— that this is no ordinary shark.
I blew through this book in about two days, reading it mostly almost exactly where it took place (Amity, in the book, is a Long Island town, not a New England island). It’s surely enjoyable, but somehow, almost disappointingly less profound than the movie. It isn’t a book about work avoidance or class warfare, but about God’s punishment of the wicked, or karma, or just the idea that even little moral compromises lead to dire results eventually.
What I didn’t know about Peter Benchley before I read the book was that he had been a speechwriter for Lyndon Johnson. He wrote the book in part because his career was derailed when Johnson declined to seek re-election in 1968. In this respect, it’s hard for me not to wonder if, somewhere in the back of the author’s head were his thoughts about how Johnson backed his way into Vietnam. He shaded the truth here, ignored a reality there, and by the time he bowed out, half a million US troops were in a quagmire. The wages of sin is death.
This is not a new moral, even for the early 70s when Jaws was first published. But like the idea that we don’t see what we don’t want to see, even on pain of death, this too is a message for our time…