Skip to content

Prof. James McAllister on 1984 and Bowie

Today’s interview features Professor James McAllister in a discussion about George Orwell’s 1984 and its influence on Bowie. Prof. McAllister is the Fred Greene Third Century Professor of Political Science at Williams College in Massachusetts. I have been wanting to do a show about 1984 specifically, not just Bowie’s related album, Diamond Dogs. I saw Prof. McAllister on Ali Velshi’s show and thought, that’s the guy I want to talk to about the book. Prof. McAllister was kind enough to agree, and the subsequent conversation was fascinating.

I would have been satisfied to simply talk about the book, but Prof. McAllister was well-versed in how the book related to Bowie, so if you’re just here for the Bowie, you’ll get what you came here for!

It’s difficult to overstate how long a shadow 1984 casts on Bowie’s artistic output. Yesterday I posted a link to him singing the “1984/DoDo” medley from his 1980 Floor Show in 1973. He released Diamond Dogs the following year, which was partially inspired by 1984. He’d continue to explore some of the themes from the book throughout his career and would make one last direct reference in one of his final songs, “Girl Loves Me” from Blackstar (2016).

The line from the song is, “I’m sitting in the chestnut tree; Who the fuck’s gonna mess with me?” The last chapter of 1984, the final sentence of which was, “He loved Big Brother,” begins with Winston literally sitting in the Chestnut Tree drinking gin. Winston is completely broken. The scene is remarkably similar to the final scene of The Man Who Fell to Earth, in which Bowie played the alien-stuck-in-human-guise, Thomas Jerome Newton.

In the movie, after years of failed attempts to break free from his earthly circumstances, Newton has been broken—physically, emotionally, and spiritually. His body has been damaged by the forced medical exams and experiments he endured. His mission derailed, his loved ones lost, Newton has lost all ambition. The closing scene features Newton sitting alone at a café, now an alcoholic, numbing himself with gin. The film ends with Newton slumped forward, exhausted and intoxicated.

Filming on The Man Who Fell to Earth began roughly a year after the release of Diamond Dogs. And Newton was on Bowie’s mind again in 2015 when he was writing “Girl Loves Me,” because Newton was the central character in the Bowie musical Lazarus. It seems that Bowie associated Newton and his circumstances with those of Winston, with one major difference.

As Winston sits in the Chestnut Tree he, or at least we the readers, know that he is doomed. Though “freed” in the sense that, now that he has been broken, the Party stops keeping close tabs on him, he has been promised that at some point he will end up with a bullet in the head (“broken man” and images of being shot in the head appear in Bowie lyrics). Newton, however, cannot die. Like the Supermen of Bowie’s 1970 song, Newton endures an endless, tragic life.

The line between death and liberation is blurred in Lazarus. To the extent that the terminally ill Bowie was conscious of his own mortality, he might have seen the Chestnut Tree as a metaphor for the corrupt world that death would free him from. Bowie wrote the line “knowledge comes with death’s release” all the way back in the 1971 song “Quicksand.” Further, alongside 1984, Bowie included Elaine Pagels’ The Gnostic Gospels on his list of influential books. Gnosticism held that the earthly realm is a prison of sorts, and that salvation involved transcending it.

Anyway, this conversation with Prof. McAllister doesn’t go down this particular rabbit hole, but there seems to be a nearly endless supply of Bowie connections to the book. And I promise, the interview is much more interesting than this!

Back To Top