
On Heathen
My interview tomorrow is with Don Klees, author of On Track: David Bowie, 1983–2016. Don had been on the show last year, and while his book covered pretty much the entirety of the second half of Bowie’s career, I felt like I wanted to talk with him at greater length about Heathen (2002). The interview was recorded in October, and I wasn’t thinking of it at the time as part of a series, but it turns out that it will serve as the first of three interviews having to do with Bowie’s spirituality. Coming in the near future are interviews with John Fugelsang, author of the bestselling book The Separation of Church and Hate, and later, Peter Ormerod, author of David Bowie and the Search for Life, Death and God. Heathen makes so much more sense with the understanding of Bowie’s intense interest in such things.

But that’s not why I initially wanted to talk with Don about the album. I wanted to talk to him because I think Heathen is a great, or at least a near-great Bowie album. But while well received at the time of its release and certainly not forgotten, it has pretty much been overshadowed by what came after. A nearly meaningless survey I did of rankings of Bowie’s albums found Heathen dead in the middle—the aggregate seems to think of Heathen as the definition of an average album.
I think it’s a lot more than that.
At one point in the interview, I comment that there are three types of songs on the album—covers, emotional songs in which Bowie is wrestling with anxiety, and scenes from the aftermath of a calamity. I initially identified “Sunday,” “5:15 The Angels Have Gone,” and “Heathen (The Rays)” as of the latter type, to which Don added “Slow Burn.”
Ormerod makes a similar observation in his book, except instead of “Slow Burn” he includes “I Will Be Your Slave” and “A Better Future,” and instead of scenes of a post-apocalypse, he identifies these as weighty songs addressed to God (p. 169). The point is that the album has a core, and the core has to do with… nothing.
Regular readers of this blog or viewers of my YouTube show know that an ongoing interest of mine is Bowie’s use of the word “nothing.” The opening line of “Sunday,” which is the opening song of the album, is “Nothing remains…”. The word populates the song, and Bowie is more explicit in assigning it contradictory meaning in that song than in any other, when he later sings, “nothing has changed / everything has changed.” Still, he doesn’t use the word as much as he does in “Heroes,” where, among other things, he reminds his lover that “we’re nothing, and nothing can help us.”
This is not a parenthetical point. Ormerod’s whole book is about Bowie’s spiritual search. “Got to keep searching and searching; oh, what will I be believing and who will connect me with love?” So goes the line in “Station to Station” (1976), which might very well be the Rosetta Stone for deciphering Bowie’s entire body of work. But by the time he gets to Heathen, Bowie comes up short. I speculate that “Sunday” is the fourth in a series of songs that began with “Five Years” (1972), which foretells the end of the world, followed by “Panic in Detroit” (1973), which depicts societal breakdown in real time, and “Diamond Dogs” (1974), which is set in the aftermath of that breakdown. Perhaps not coincidentally, “Sunday” takes place much later, when, to repeat that opening line, “nothing remains.” And I do think that works.
But in the larger context of the album, the vast wasteland of “Sunday” is also spiritual. Bowie had been searching and searching yet, to paraphrase a different song by a different band, still hadn’t found what he was looking for. Another song, one of those emotional songs, “Afraid,” has the narrator reciting his beliefs and his practices—he does everything right. But he’s still afraid. The album ends with the title track (of sorts), which really does seem to be the coda both of “Station to Station” as well as “Sound and Vision” (1976) and a bunch of other Bowie songs:
“Waiting for something; looking for someone; is there no reason? Have I stared too long?”
The song doesn’t pivot and conclude with a happy, hopeful ending.
So, why “Heathen?” It’s not a word I really thought much about, even in the context of the album. The word basically means “nonbeliever,” but it isn’t synonymous with “atheist.” It can carry as broad a meaning as “uncivilized” or even just “strange,” or as specific as “non-Christian.” All this aligns with how Bowie described himself. And since several of the songs either seem to be directed at God or use religious imagery without embracing any particular religious tradition or even arriving at any conclusions, it is in alignment with the main theme of the album, too.

So, what’s with the eyes? From the moment I first saw the album cover, now nearly a quarter-century ago, I couldn’t help but think of Tor Johnson, the Swedish pro wrestler as a zombie in the infamously bad movie Plan 9 from Outer Space (1957). Ormerod says the eyes are supposed to look like fish eyes (“Christians used a symbol of a fish as a secret way to identify themselves while they were persecuted in pagan times,” p. 167). Is Bowie not staring blankly, then? Is he staring solemnly? Purposefully?
Blindness also works. Blindness is a recurring theme in Bowie songs, perhaps most obviously as manifested by his final character, “Buttoneyes,” who appears in the videos for “Lazarus” and “Blackstar” (2016). Perhaps the cover of Heathen features a younger Buttoneyes, without his bandage.
The album title and song are not the first time Bowie used the word “heathen.” His seemingly anti-religious song “Loving the Alien” (1984) includes the line, “Pray and the heathen lie will disappear” (the word “blind” also appears in the song). But the song makes a mockery out of prayer, suggesting it is a distraction from real-world problems. Perhaps Bowie has been blinded by the light. Or, per the earlier song, since a heathen lie can disappear, it is something that can be seen in the first place. Perhaps that lie, made manifest, obstructs Bowie’s true sight.
Or maybe he was trying to look like Tor Johnson. The album includes some comic relief, like “Slip Away,” a song that is at once poignant while at the same time being about a local children’s show that Bowie used to find (perhaps unintentionally) hilarious. It also contains a cover by the Legendary Stardust Cowboy, “I Took a Trip on a Gemini Spaceship.” The album gets weighty, but Bowie might be signaling not to take the whole thing too seriously.
In any case, Bowie was at his best when he wasn’t being too obvious. And if he’s not at his best here, he’s much closer than you might think.
—
Come back tomorrow for much more on Heathen, with my guest, Don Klees.