Skip to content

Daniel Rachel on Pop Music’s Fascination with Nazis

Daniel Rachel returned to my show for a second discussion of his book, This Ain’t Rock ’n’ Roll: Pop Music, the Swastika and the Third Reich. Whereas our first conversation focused largely on David Bowie’s role within the book, this discussion examined the book’s broader themes and arguments.

A major topic was Rachel’s explanation of why he wrote the book. He argued that many of the incidents and stories it contains have long been publicly available, but that they had not previously been assembled into a single narrative. We discussed the three categories of artists identified in the book: those who explicitly embraced Nazi ideas, those who used Nazi imagery without an obvious political commitment, and those who actively opposed fascism. Much of our conversation centered on the second category and the possibility that the use of Nazi symbols can influence audiences regardless of an artist’s stated intentions.

We also discussed the relationship between propaganda, spectacle, and popular culture. Rachel described Nazi imagery as having been deliberately designed to create powerful visual and emotional effects, and argued that later musicians and performers often drew upon those same qualities. This led to a discussion of artists including Roger Waters, Kraftwerk, Nick Cave, Lemmy, Brian Ferry, Mick Jagger, David Bowie, Gene Simmons, Queen, Lady Gaga, and Nicki Minaj. Throughout the conversation, we examined how ambiguity functions in art, whether audiences can reasonably be expected to interpret symbols as intended, and how different viewers can reach very different conclusions about the same work.

Another recurring theme was the appeal of mass participation and collective experience. We compared descriptions of Nazi rallies with accounts of rock concerts and discussed why large public gatherings can produce feelings of emotional surrender, identification, and shared purpose. Rachel emphasized the distinction between the experience of communal enjoyment at a concert and political movements that employ similar techniques in pursuit of ideological goals.

The conversation also explored historical memory and the continuing fascination with Nazism in popular culture. Rachel discussed the role of propaganda, uniforms, visual presentation, and political mythology in shaping public perceptions of the Third Reich. We talked about why Nazi symbolism continues to reappear in music, film, and other forms of entertainment more frequently than imagery associated with many other authoritarian movements.

Finally, we discussed contemporary politics and culture, including the public statements and activities of modern artists, debates over antisemitism, the responsibilities of performers and audiences, and the importance of context when interpreting controversial imagery. We also returned briefly to David Bowie, discussing the extent to which his interest in Nazism during the 1970s is addressed in Bowie scholarship and public discussions of his work.

Back To Top