Skip to content

Daniel Rachel Preview

David Bowie plays a prominent role in Daniel Rachel’s book, This Ain’t Rock ‘n’ Roll: Pop Music, the Swastika, and the Third Reich, and the last time he appeared on my show as a guest, that’s what we talked about. But Rachel’s book isn’t specifically about Bowie and I wanted to talk to him about the broader topic, which covers pop music’s roughly 70-year relationship to Nazism. So I’m grateful that he agreed to come back, and will appear as my guest on tomorrow’s episode of my YouTube show.

I found much about Rachel’s book to be compelling, including the idea that regardless of the intent of pop stars’ use of Nazi imagery, the effect, depending on context, can be to help normalize Nazism. Rachel’s book often is careful to distinguish between actual Nazism and other forms of bigoted ways of thinking. For instance, he pointed out that the Rock Against Racism movement in the late 70s and early 80s was more about opposing racism in general and underemphasized antisemitism, even when railing against fascists and Nazis. As used by Nazis and their fellow-travelers, the swastika, Rachel points out, is specifically an antisemitic symbol.

I understand that the origins of bigoted mythologies differ depending on their targets, but hate in many forms is on the rise today in many parts of the world, including where I live. I live in the United States, where the government’s ruling coalition is doing its best to normalize hate as the default way we interact with each other as human beings. That’s a deliberately broad statement, but I don’t want to lose the big picture just because there’s more evidence supporting narrower assertions. Hatred directed toward trans people or immigrants is not the same as antisemitism, but it’s all hate.

But antisemitism appears to be on the rise, even where I live in New York State. To that extent, pop stars adding fuel to the fire by playing around with Nazi imagery can translate into real harm, again regardless of their intentions. At the risk of making excuses for my guy, Bowie, at this point I don’t think he’s part of the problem. Whatever his motivations were for making pro-fascist-sounding statements in the 70s and indicating an interest in the Nazis in other ways as well, by the end of his life he had long since distanced himself from all that. Rachel’s book itself stirred up recollections of Bowie’s interest in the topic. In the interview, Rachel makes a good point that much of the posthumous interest in Bowie tends to shy away from this topic—what, indeed, was he up to? I have thoughts, but for purposes of this post I feel like I’m on solid ground in asserting that David Bowie is not remembered as a fascist sympathizer.

But political and cultural figures that are very much alive and active today have appropriated the symbolism and imagery of Nazis. Just sticking with the U.S., examples include Elon Musk’s Nazi salute, Trump’s revival of the “America First” slogan, first popularized by the Nazi-adjacent movement trying to keep the U.S. out of World War II, the stage used by the 2021 CPAC convention shaped like a Nazi symbol, border enforcer Gregory Bovino’s Nazi-style uniform and hairstyle, and Maine Democratic Senate candidate Graham Platner’s (since removed) Nazi tattoo, among many others. In the U.S., the apparent rise of antisemitism is not limited to either Republicans or Democrats; however, to make a knowingly too-broad oversimplification, antisemitism on the right more often appears alongside explicit Nazi symbolism and rhetoric, whereas on the left it more often manifests through hostility connected to Israel.

There is plenty of evidence that antisemitism is on the rise. To cite one source, the Anti-Defamation League’s 2024 Audit of Antisemitic Incidents showed that the United States recorded a record 9,354 antisemitic incidents—up 5% from 2023 and nearly ninefold over the past decade—and that assaults, vandalism, and campus incidents increased sharply, with the highest totals occurring in my state of New York as well as California. I can easily go down the rabbit hole of citing evidence, but this is a blog post—if you’re interested, I recommend Google.

The point, though, is that politicians and influencers are not the only cultural stewards shaping attitudes on the topic. So too are figures like Kanye West, who appears to be openly pro-Nazi (and certainly uses the swastika). West—Ye—actually ran for president. He didn’t do well, but it is certainly plausible that he helped move some traditionally Democratic voters away from Kamala Harris toward Trump, who we should all feel comfortable now recognizing as a fascist. Daniel Rachel mentioned a Nicki Minaj video that uses Nazi imagery. There’s no mistaking the images in the video for her song, “Only,” in which, among other things, she is depicted in cartoon form as a Führer-like figure. Rachel seemed surprised that she’s become active in MAGA politics. I can appreciate that the MAGA style of fascism is not exactly the same as that of 1930s German Nazis, but it seems to me that there’s a big difference between what Minaj and West are doing in using the symbols while aligning with the available, contemporary version of American fascism and, say, what Lady Gaga was doing wearing an outfit evocative of a Nazi uniform at a Hillary Clinton rally. Not to put too fine a point on it, but Gaga was taking action to oppose fascism. West openly advocates fascism and Minaj, at the very least has chosen to associate her brand with far-right politics. Why did Gaga choose to wear a Nazi-like outfit? I have no earthly idea, but she did so while doing the opposite of advocating Nazism.

You can see that there’s so much more to discuss, which was the impetus behind asking Daniel Rachel to come back. So you, too, should come back tomorrow for this compelling interview.

If you missed Daniel Rachel’s first visit on my show, check it out here:

Back To Top