Skip to content

Albums I’d Rather have than the Shel Talmy Recordings, Part 1: Live Covers Omitted from Studio Albums

When I started composing this post, my intent was to articulate why I’m not overly excited about the pending release of The Shel Talmy Recordings, 21 tracks recorded by Bowie in 1965, including ten that have not previously been released. But the more I was thinking about it, the more my mind went to albums I’d rather see released. I’ve posted about that type of thing before, but what I want to do here is include links to an album’s worth of thematically coherent Bowie recordings that have never been collected on an official Bowie album. The theme in this case is live covers of songs that Bowie did not include on any studio album.

Before I get to that I should explain my ambivalence about the Shel Talmy Recordings, which is due to be released in September. I’ve ordered the album and I’m not going to argue that it shouldn’t exist at all, at least not before I hear it. But 60s Bowie is my least favorite Bowie era. His output from this time is obscure for a reason. And the prospect that ten recordings have not found their way into circulation in the ensuing 61 years does not fill me with confidence that they will have a lot of replay value.

And that’s it— I’m expecting the album to include some curiosities that feature Bowie’s underdeveloped, high-pitched nasally voice from the period, and yeah, I’d rather they be released in such a collection than not, but I can imagine albums I’d want more.

So, I’m going to start with these 12 songs featuring Bowie performing songs live that he did not release as studio recordings on any official album. This is not comprehensive — you easily might be thinking of a few that I’m not including here. I’m not making a deliberate editorial choice but rather show that there’s at least an album’s worth of such material out there. And, of course, all of this is already out there, at least on YouTube. But no such compilation album exists. If it did, I’d listen to it more than once. (We can get into a discussion about the age of streaming at another time). Anyway, here it goes, starting with…

1. “Imagine”. Bowie performed the John Lennon song in 1983 during the Serious Moonlight tour around the third anniversary of his friend’s assassination. This one even got an “official video” treatment, and to my ears, sounds great.

2. “Arnold Layne”. Bowie joined David Gilmour in 2006 to perform the Pink Floyd song that partially inspired Bowie’s own Arnold Corns project. You can hear this on a collection released by Gilmour, and my understanding is that its included in material from the I Can’t Give Everything Away box set, but if you already have all of Bowie’s studio albums, would you rather get one new one that compiles these types of live performances or an entire, largely duplicative box set in order to get a few bonus tracks?

3. “America”. This Simon and Garfunkel cover is my favorite live Bowie performance, recorded at the Concert for New York in 2001. I have the double CD of that event, but Bowie’s just on it for two songs, and I don’t think it’s in print anymore anyway.

4. “Lust for Life”. Bowie was heavily involved in the Iggy Pop album of the same name and performed the title track on tour in 1996. Of all the songs on this list, this is the one I find strangest to hear Bowie singing, I guess because I associate it so closely with Iggy.

5. “Sister Midnight”. Another song I associate with Iggy Pop, that Bowie had a hand in back when Iggy recorded it for The Idiot in 1976. Rather than record his own version, Bowie took the music and came up with new lyrics for what became “Red Money” on Lodger. Another version of Bowie performing this live is included on his A Reality Tour live album, but this video is from the Isle of Wight Festival in 2004.

6. “Hurt”. Nine Inch Nails opened for Bowie during the Outside Tour in 1995. Instead of finishing their set and walking off stage, Bowie would join the opening act on stage and do some songs together as members of Bowie’s band replaced members of NIN. Trent Reznor would later say one of the greatest moments of his life was standing next to Bowie while he performed this song.

7. “Gloria”. I remember Bowie’s performance of this Van Morrison song as a standout moment from his Sound and Vision Tour, at least when I saw it in Hartford, Connecticut in 1990. (By the way, there’s no official live album from that tour). I guess he did it as part of a medley with “The Jean Genie” and… “Maria?” There’s a great audio-only recording of Bowie and Bono singing this together, but I’m linking to Bowie on his own here because there’s a (possibly bootlegged) video.

8. Two Elvis songs. Sadly, this is an audio-only recording of Bowie paying homage to The King in 2002 with two covers, “I Feel So Bad” and “One Night.” I think Bowie sounds great doing these two, and maybe more than anything else on this list, these would benefit from being cleaned up a little and getting an official release.

9. “Foot Stompin’” This cover includes a Carlos Alomar guitar riff that Bowie liked so much he, Alomar and John Lennon used it to create an entirely new song, “Fame.” This clip from The Dick Cavett Show in 1974 is easy to come by and was included on a compilation album called RarestOneBowie, but that album has been out of print for years and most of the other songs on it are no longer rare.

10. “Dirty Boulevard” Here’s another concert that hasn’t made its way into becoming an official live album— Bowie’s 50th birthday party in 1997. He was joined by several special guests including Lou Reed who did this song together.

11. “Debaser”. Tin Machine covered this Pixies song in 1989. Why it wasn’t included on their obscure live album, Oy Vey Baby, and “Stateside” was is a mystery to me. In the performance captured by this lousy video, Bowie is not on lead vocals, but I’d include it, especially if the audio can be cleaned up a bit.

12. “I Got You Babe”. Bowie and Marianne Faithfull, both looking at the weirdest, performed this Sonny & Cher song as part of the Nineteen Eighty Floor Show (in 1973), which also exists as an album only as what’s either a bootleg or an out-of-print poorly engineered one-off. Bowie’s performances from the show can easily be found on The Midnight Special’s YouTube page, but as far as I know, this song was never released in a form that sounds any good on an official album.

Like I said, this list can easily be much, much longer, especially if you weren’t too concerned about avoiding songs that have appeared as bonus tracks elsewhere.

Back To Top