Skip to content

Susan Compo on The Man Who Fell to Earth Preview

2026 is the 50th anniversary year for The Man Who Fell to Earth, the first movie in which David Bowie starred. If “David Bowie” is a kind of meta-character, the crafted fictional alter ego of the artist David Jones, then The Man Who Fell to Earth is more inseparably linked to that character’s identity than any other role Bowie took on (perhaps ironically, the nearest competitor is Jareth the Goblin King, but that’s another story). It is often said that Bowie didn’t really have to act in the movie, he’s just playing David Bowie (though it’s interesting to think about how Jones was acting while being Bowie).

So, the movie is essential to the larger David Bowie canon. For that reason I wanted to do at least one episode on my show about it during this calendar year, and tomorrow I will post an interview with the woman who wrote the book on the topic, Susan Compo. Susan’s book, Earthbound: David Bowie and The Man Who Fell to Earth, tells the story of the making of the movie, which is a much more interesting story than I was expecting. I guess what I was expecting her book to be was some sort of extended movie review, which it isn’t. Instead, the book presented its own compelling narrative, that also happened to star David Bowie. So, our discussion is absolutely about The Man Who Fell to Earth, but perhaps not exactly in the way you might expect.

At one point I asked Susan if we would even be having our discussion if Bowie were not in the movie. And, given that the conceit of my show is that all the topics link back to Bowie, the answer of course is that we would not. But that’s not what I meant. The Man Who Fell to Earth is a challenging movie to actually watch. Despite top-rate performances from excellent actors including Candy Clark, Rip Torn and Buck Henry, the story is jumbled and the editing is, as Susan discusses, an infamous mess (though that partially depends on what cut of the movie you happen to be watching). Bowie is not so much the glue that holds the movie together— arguably the movie does not hold together— but he’s a mesmerizing magnet that draws our attention. He’s hard to not watch, and despite the screenplay’s deliberately opaque narrative, Bowie as an alienated, tragic and misunderstood failed messiah comes through every bit as much on the Ziggy Stardust album.

To that end, The Man Who Fell to Earth is one of several movies in which Bowie acts out themes he also addresses in his music. At the heart of Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence are the motivations of Bowie’s character, Jack Celliers, as shaped by memories of his relationship with his brother. Bowie’s mentally ill half-brother, Terry Burns, influenced works ranging from The Man Who Sold the World to “Jump They Say.” The not-very-good Just a Gigolo features Bowie as a good-looking but naive young man willing to literally prostitute himself to make a living who unwittingly drifts into the orbit of the emerging Nazi movement, only to be killed and have his corpse used by those same Nazis as propaganda. Bowie made the movie in the wake of his own seemingly pro-fascist statements being embraced by the far-right National Front and provoking backlash from the nascent Rock Against Racism movement.

The Man Who Fell to Earth, released three years after Bowie killed off Ziggy Stardust, at once put a final nail in that coffin— Bowie would never again portray a space alien either on stage or on screen. But it also exposed the metaphors embedded within Ziggy and connected them to what would follow. As if to underscore the place of this movie in Bowie’s musical continuity, he used images from it for the cover art of both Station to Station (1976) and Low (1977).

But The Man Who Fell to Earth is not a musical film. Bowie mostly doesn’t sing in the movie (Susan’s book reminds me that the exception is a scene in a church, but even then he barely sings). His music was not used in the soundtrack. The only overt allusion to Bowie as rock-star is a visual joke, where, near the end of the movie, copies of Young Americans can be seen in the background during a scene that takes place in a record store.

Bowie’s character, Thomas Jerome Newton, does not age in the movie even as other, human characters do. The movie plays with time and never fully explains how or why, but 50 years later this lands differently than it might have in 1976. By that I mean that ten years after Bowie’s death, he is forever 29 in this movie. More than that, the movie serves as a time capsule of Bowie as rock star. Of course Bowie would die a rock star, but he had long since moved beyond being an object of youthful enthusiasm that adults just didn’t understand. The idea that Bowie, here, was the draw for this movie, that some young people would actually be disappointed at the time because they might have been expecting something like a Ziggy musical, that there was a novelty to Bowie starring in a movie would all be difficult to reverse engineer from the guy who made The Next Day and Blackstar, regardless of those albums’ popularity and critical acclaim. The mere existence of Bowie in 1976 was a threat to the social order, and represented a dividing line between young and old.

Susan tells me in the interview that she more or less lost interest in Bowie with the emergence of punk, which tracks with what I’m getting at. I was reminded of an anecdote in Suzie Ronson’s book about her life with Mick Ronson, Me and Mr. Jones, where they go to a punk club and, despite not yet being 30, were looked at like they were yesterday’s news. Low often tops lists of Bowie’s best records, but by the year of Bowie’s 30th birthday, his appeal, and his audience had subtly shifted already.

As Susan chronicles, The Man Who Fell to Earth was not a hit. It was received with mixed reviews. Within months, Star Wars redefined expectations of what a science fiction film was supposed to be. It wasn’t quite forgotten, but the full impact of The Man Who Fell to Earth took time to permeate the broader cultural landscape. But, by 2026, it has. This year, several of the movies I have reviewed in my “drive-in Saturday Tuesday Movie Review” series have involved space aliens, and several of those movies appear to have been influenced, if only subtly, by the Bowie movie. As I wrote earlier in the week, a brief scene in Supergirl appears to pay overt visual homage to the movie, as a character in that film emerges from a spaceship on an alien world and descends a rocky hill just like Newton.

Bowie as Thomas Jermone Newton, arriving on Earth

Descent is key to the movie, and perhaps signaled to future science fiction screenwriters how it can be a useful metaphor for them, too. This is probably better addressed in a future post, but think about how descent really is not a theme in Star Wars, but very much is in Steven Spielberg’s alien movies, including this year’s Disclosure Day, as well as seemingly more frivolous movies like Supergirl or last year’s Superman. (Even Spielberg’s 1978 movie, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, was made after The Man Who Fell to Earth, unlike Star Wars). How much were the future filmmakers consciously influenced by The Man? I don’t know, but it’s hard to imagine they had not seen it.

Anyway, as you can tell, there’s much more to write about this movie, and there’s much more to say. Fortunately, you’ll get a chance to hear more on the topic from Susan Compo, so be sure to come back tomorrow for that!

—

Susan Compo grew up in California, where she published an influential music fanzine during the punk era. She is the author of fiction and nonfiction books, including Earthbound: David Bowie and The Man Who Fell to Earth. She also recently collaborated with artist Mark Wardel, who has also been a guest on my show, on the book David Bowie and “Cracked Actor”: The Fly in the Milk. She is currently working on a biography of playwright and actor Sam Shepard.

Back To Top